Volume profile and the market auction
Cracks, spreads and flows move crude. Auction market theory shows where the market accepts the move. This is the framework: how value is defined, where the levels come from, what counts as acceptance, and how the barrel decides which levels hold.
The market is an auction
Price advertises for the other side. It moves until it finds enough opposing business to stop. Time and volume at a price tell you whether the advert worked: build time and volume, accepted; trade thin and leave fast, rejected.
Two states:
- Balance. Two-sided trade around agreed value, rotating between the extremes. The default. In crude it can last weeks between catalysts.
- Imbalance. One side in control because information changed fair value. Price moves until it finds enough opposing trade to start a new balance.
Every note answers three questions:
- Where is value? See timeframes.
- Is price away from value accepted or rejected? Time, volume, and what the developing value area does.
- Who is in control? Initiative buyers building value higher, initiative sellers building it lower, or responsive trade pulling price back to the middle.
The data behind the profiles
Data. Profiles are built from exchange futures, NYMEX WTI (CL) and ICE Brent (B), so volume is contract volume, not tick volume. Levels use the most active contract month by volume. Composites that span a roll are rebuilt on the new contract only, so old-contract value is never carried into the new one. CFD and spot quotes trade at a basis to futures, so levels on a broker chart sit off by that amount. Posts before 16th November 2026 used a CFD feed (USOUSD).
The levels
Point of control (PoC)
Highest-volume price. Fair value for the period. In balance it's a magnet and slows price, because both sides will trade there. A distant PoC is a target. Price sitting on the PoC means slow, two-sided trade. Size down your expectations.
Value area (VA), value area high (VaH) and value area low (VaL)
The range holding about 70% of the volume, built out from the PoC by adding the heavier adjacent price each step. The edges are where opinion gets tested: responsive sellers above VaH, responsive buyers below VaL. Acceptance or rejection outside value decides most setups here. See acceptance.
High-volume node (HVN)
A secondary volume peak, a smaller area of agreement. Depth on both sides, so it slows price: support, resistance or a pause. Strength scales with time spent building it. A multi-day balance holds far more inventory than a node built in a few hours, and takes far more trade to clear.
Low-volume node (LVN)
A volume trough, left where one side was in control and price moved too fast for two-sided trade. Two jobs:
- Boundary. It usually separates two value areas. First return from either side gets a reaction.
- Transit. Once price is accepted inside it, it travels through to the next HVN. An LVN is not support or resistance.
Naked (untested) PoC
A prior PoC not yet revisited. Unfinished business, and a target until it trades.
Developing PoC and value
Intraday PoC and value area. A developing PoC following price confirms value is being built there. Price extending while the developing PoC lags means the move isn't accepted yet.
| Level | Definition | Behaviour |
|---|---|---|
| PoC | Highest-volume price | Magnet in balance |
| VaH | Top of the 70% value area | Responsive selling; acceptance above = value moving up |
| VaL | Bottom of the 70% value area | Responsive buying; acceptance below = value moving down |
| HVN | Secondary volume peak | Support and resistance; slows a move |
| LVN | Volume trough | Reaction on first test; fast transit once accepted inside |
| Naked PoC | Prior PoC not revisited | Target; dead once traded through |
Levels are zones. Feeds and session settings shift them by a few ticks. Setups here give an entry zone and put the stop beyond the level, not on it.
Profile shape
A finished session's shape records who ran the auction.
D-shape: balance. Volume centred, tapering at both ends. Without new information, rotation inside value next session.
P-shape. Thin lower tail, volume built at the top. Often short covering, not fresh buying. It runs out once the shorts are out.
b-shape. Thin upper tail, volume built at the bottom. Often long liquidation, not fresh selling.
Thin profile: trend. Volume spread thin over a wide range. One side drove it and value never formed.
Double distribution. Two value areas split by an LVN. Value relocated intraday, usually on news.
A single-print tail at an extreme is excess: the market overshot, found nobody and reversed hard. Durable high or low. A session that closes flat on its high or low with no tail leaves a poor high or poor low, an unfinished auction that usually gets revisited.
Balance, imbalance and value migration
Where value sits session to session is the main read on control.
| Value vs prior session | Read |
|---|---|
| Higher, no overlap | Buyers in control; value migrating up |
| Overlapping, higher | Tentative up; buyers have the edge |
| Inside | Balance; waiting on information |
| Outside both sides | Two-sided expansion; often precedes a bigger move |
| Overlapping, lower | Tentative down; sellers have the edge |
| Lower, no overlap | Sellers in control; value migrating down |
The longer a balance holds, the more inventory inside it, the more stops outside it, the bigger the break. In crude the trigger is usually fundamental: EIA, OPEC+, a Gulf headline.
Initiative and responsive trade
- Responsive: opposing a move away from value. Selling above VaH, buying below VaL. Keeps balance.
- Initiative: following a move away from value. Buying above VaH, selling below VaL. Once accepted, it builds new value.
Responsive trade at the edges is normal in balance. Accepted initiative trade starts an imbalance. Fading it is how balance profits get handed back.
Acceptance and rejection
Most setups here come down to whether price leaving value is accepted or rejected.
A break is accepted when:
- price closes beyond the level on the execution timeframe (usually hourly here);
- a retest from the far side holds;
- the developing PoC and value area move towards the new prices.
Rejection: a probe outside value that builds no time or volume and comes back fast, often leaving a tail. Above VaH that's a look above and fail. Below VaL, a look below and fail. Both point to the other side of value.
The 80% rule (an open outside value that re-enters and holds for two 30-minute periods tends to cross the value area) is a tendency, not a statistic. The logic holds anyway: once a break fails, the far side of value is the next place with real trade.
Volume on the break
The profile shows where volume traded. Time-series volume shows whether a move has participation. Each bar's range against its volume, relative to recent bars on the same feed:
Wide range, high volume. Participation confirms the move.
Narrow range, low volume. Nobody pressing. Tells you nothing.
Wide range, low volume. Unsupported, easily reversed. Typical of headline spikes in thin liquidity.
Narrow range, high volume. Heavy trade, no progress. Opposing orders are absorbing the move. Often the first sign it's tiring.
Same test over a sequence. A trend with expanding volume has participation. Extension on fading volume means fewer people pressing. Vulnerable.
Breakouts and retests
The best check uses both. A break that gets accepted usually comes on expanding volume, because moving price off established value takes real participation. The retest should come on light volume, showing the other side isn't back in size, then volume expands again as the move develops.
The warnings are the inverse. A break on light volume is a probe nobody backed. It usually rotates back into value. A retest on heavy volume at the old level means the other side is back. The break is in doubt.
Volume spikes
- Spike after an extended move. Sharp volume at the end of a long run, often with a long wick and a close off the extreme: late entry or forced exit. If the next bars don't extend, the leg is done, and the profile usually shows excess there.
- Sustained heavy volume, no progress. Repeated high-volume, narrow-range bars at one price. Opposing orders are absorbing everything. It leaves an HVN that acts as support or resistance later.
The open
Where the open sits against the prior session's range and value sets the likely day type.
Inside value. Balance continues. Rotate VaH to VaL: fade the edges, trade a break only once accepted.
Outside value, inside range. Tests whether prior value still holds. Re-entry and acceptance target the far side of value. Holding outside means value is moving.
Outside range. Strongest imbalance signal, often after overnight or weekend news. No quick return into range, trend day in play, early fades are poor.
Early activity grades conviction. An open drive away without a retest: high conviction. A test of a reference then a drive the other way: less. Two-sided rotation around the open: still in balance, waiting.
Timeframes and composite profiles
Three profile types:
- Daily (session) profiles. Prior session's PoC, VaH, VaL frame the next one. Prefixed d (dPoC, dVaH, dVaL).
- Composite profiles. Several sessions merged, usually the last 5 or the full current balance. Bigger-picture value. They outrank single sessions.
- Higher-timeframe profiles. Weekly and monthly. Major value areas and the LVNs between them, where trends run.
Levels that line up across timeframes (a daily VaH just under a composite VaH, say) count for more than either alone. When they conflict, the higher timeframe usually wins: a daily breakout into a composite HVN is a trade into resistance. Each post's level board says which profile every label comes from.
VWAP and anchored VWAP
PoC is the most-traded price. VWAP is the average price paid. Above session VWAP, that session's participants are in profit on average. Below it, they're under water and sell rallies.
Anchored VWAPs run from events that reset positioning: an EIA release, an OPEC+ decision, a major swing. It's the average entry of everyone active since. It holds as support or resistance in a trend that started there. A sustained break means the event's move is being unwound.
Cracks, spreads, flows and the profile
The profile shows where value is. The barrel shows why it moves and whether the move sticks. Three reads, every session, before any level:
- Spreads. WTI and Brent timespreads, front to Q1. Value migrating higher with prompt backwardation widening is initiative buying with physical behind it. Value migrating higher with spreads flat is paper, and it rotates back. Expiry squeezes in the front month are stripped out: read the next spread down.
- Cracks. Diesel and gasoline cracks and the 3-2-1. Strong cracks keep refiners buying crude and put a floor under dips into value. A crack rolling over removes that floor.
- Flows. Brent–WTI for the export arb, Cushing for the hub, US exports and Gulf Coast runs. A wide arb pulls US barrels out and drains coast stocks. A building hub flattens WTI's curve whatever the headline stock number says.
EIA is the clearest case. On 15th October an 8.6M bbl draw drove WTI out of balance around $94.1, through the composite PoC and above the composite VaH, leaving an LVN behind. The detail said otherwise: exports and lost output did the drawing, Cushing built 1.9M bbl and Brent–WTI collapsed by $2.8 in one session. The breakout had no follow-through barrels, and the next session came straight back to the daily VaH.
Big headlines don't always move value. A spike that comes straight back into value is a rejection: the market priced the news and decided fair value hasn't changed. If spreads didn't move with it, the war premium moved, not the barrel.
The process behind each note
- The barrel first. Timespreads, cracks, Brent–WTI, Cushing, exports. Which way is physical leaning, and is it leaning harder or softer than yesterday?
- Higher timeframe. Composite PoC, VaH, VaL, main HVNs and LVNs, higher-timeframe support and resistance. Balancing or trending?
- Prior session. PoC, VaH, VaL, naked PoCs, poor highs and lows, excess.
- Value placement. Prior session's value against the one before. Who's in control, and does the curve agree?
- Calendar. EIA, API, expiries, OPEC+. Size down around them.
- Pivot and scenarios. The level that decides the session. Plan for acceptance above and below, targets at the next levels each way.
- Execution. No entry until the level is accepted or rejected. Volume checked on the break and the retest. Stop where the thesis fails, usually back inside the value price was meant to leave.
Every daily note follows this: the barrel, a pivot, a long on acceptance above, a short on acceptance below, targets at the next volume levels.
Where the read goes wrong
- Reading the level without the barrel. A break of value on a headline, with spreads flat and cracks fading, gets reclaimed.
- Levels as lines. They're zones. Stops go beyond them.
- Fading every break of value. Responsive trades pay in balance and get run over in imbalance. Know the state first.
- LVN as support. Once accepted inside, the next HVN is the target.
- Ignoring the higher timeframe. A daily breakout into a composite HVN is a trade into resistance.
- Trusting a low-volume break. Not a breakout until volume and acceptance confirm it.
- Acting on the first touch. The touch tells you little. The response tells you everything.
- Mixing data sources. Futures, CFD and session settings place levels differently. Pick one.
Notation
- aVWAP
- Anchored VWAP, from a chosen event or swing instead of the session open.
- Composite
- Several sessions merged, usually the last 5 or the current balance.
- dPoC, dVaH, dVaL
- Prior session's PoC, value area high and value area low.
- Excess
- Single-print tail at an extreme. Strong high or low.
- HVN, LVN
- High- and low-volume nodes: peaks and troughs in the profile.
- Naked PoC
- Prior PoC not yet revisited.
- PoC
- Point of control: highest-volume price.
- Poor high, poor low
- Session extreme with no tail. Unfinished auction.
- VA, VaH, VaL
- Value area (about 70% of volume around the PoC) and its edges.
- VWAP
- Volume-weighted average price for the period.
Further reading
J. Peter Steidlmayer, who built market profile at the CBOT in the 1980s; James Dalton, Mind Over Markets and Markets in Profile.
This page describes the method behind the analysis on this site and is not a recommendation to trade. Volume levels show where the market has traded, not where it will go. Read the risk disclaimer before trading on any idea from this site.